Meador Manor

Thrilling & Manipulative

Posted on August 20, 2026 by Granger Meador

These days the U.S. adult genre fiction market perhaps breaks down into about 2/5 romance, 1/3 crime/mystery/thrillers, and 1/4 science fiction/fantasy. Within the second genre group, I’m much more interested in mysteries than modern thrillers.

Years ago I did enjoy a few of Thomas Harris‘s crackling thrillers, which translated easily into theatrical films. Occasionally a cozier classic mystery author like Agatha Christie or Edith Pargeter (writing as Ellis Peters) would bring thriller elements into their stories, and recently I’ve enjoyed the decades-old suspense romance books of Mary Stewart.

Having read so many mysteries from the 1890s to the 1960s, a recent thriller from 2019 was a jolt. Needing a break from my Kindle, I had sauntered into my office and opened the glass doors to the retirement reading bookcase. For some time I’ve collected in it various physical books to be read when my pace of life slowed. Many were purchased over the years at Barnes and Noble, while others are more obscure out-of-print works, unavailable as typical e-books, which I ordered from used booksellers. My plan had long been to start whittling away at that woodpile in my retirement. Now I was a few weeks into that new phase of my life, with the miserable heat and humidity of July in Joklahoma restricting my walking to early mornings, leaving afternoons free for reading.

On one shelf I spied Never Tell by Lisa Gardner. I had never heard of her, and the trade paperback had been published in 2019. I figured it was something I spotted at Barnes and Noble that got lost in the COVID-19 pandemonium that disrupted my life for several years.

It turned out to be #11 in Gardner’s series with Boston detective D.D. Warren, consisting of a dozen novels and four shorter e-books from 2004 to 2020. Since then, Gardner has reportedly shifted to focus on a new thriller series featuring an amateur investigator.

Never Tell consists of chapters that continually shift between first person narratives of three women: Detective Warren, past crime victim Flora Dane, and a pregnant woman who may have killed her father and then, years later, her husband. The changing perspectives helped make the set-up more interesting, and I was grateful to not be stuck for an extended period in the damaged minds of Dane and the apparent killer. The pace eventually began to drag, with too many unresolved mysteries piling up, but then Gardner hit the gas with some breakthroughs and action.

I haven’t really been interested in solving whodunits since I was a kid, instead enjoying the ride with the characters. In this case, my suspicions proved accurate, but were sufficiently delayed to prevent me from skimming. However, I didn’t think some episodes were believable, especially the climax, which featured a long-winded and overly composed confrontation in extreme circumstances that reminded me of some of the unrealistic TV thrillers of my youth.

It was nice to read a tale with modern technology, and the female characters dominated this tale, being far more active and commanding than those in the older genre works. I deemed this extraction from the retirement case a success, but I certainly wouldn’t want to follow it with another thriller.

So instead I picked up a Kindle science fiction novel from 2018 by Alan Dean Foster. He has written dozens of novelizations of science fiction television shows and movies, and as a kid, I devoured his Star Trek Log adaptations of that franchise’s animated series from 1973-1974. Now I was finally reading one of his dozens of books that weren’t media tie-ins.

Relic started quite strong, with elegiac chapters about a man believed to be the last surviving human on a distant colony world. His tale of survival and becoming a research subject for conservation-minded aliens was fascinating, and Foster drew from his extensive world travels to help him flesh out alien environments.

However, eventually other humans entered the picture, and the book ended with an unsatisfying deus ex machina that relied upon advanced technologies that miraculously survive long periods of neglect, rather reminiscent of the unrealities of Tim Huntley’s One on Me I encountered last autumn.

After cleansing my palate with the penultimate finished Blandings Castle book, 1965’s Galahad at Blandings, I read an Ellis Peters/Edith Pargeter novella and then took up the Kindle version of The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry, a tearjerker about an aged British pensioner who embarks on a long walk across that immense island to see a woman in a hospice. Longlisted for the Booker Prize in 2012, the book had several moving chapters, with poignant vignettes of lost souls. However, once the protagonist gained various repulsive hangers-on, I was far less enthused. Thankfully they were eventually shed, but the bleak end of his journey was shattering. Various mysteries, the solutions to which I had already guessed at, were finally resolved, but the renewal of his fraught relationship with his wife was perhaps a bit too realistic. It was an existential read with few guideposts.

I guess my primary objection to The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry was how its manipulations did not feel organic to the story. The characters knew vital truths not shared with the reader for most of the walk, merely hinted at. I prefer characters who are as much in the dark as I am, lighting matches which they thrust into the surrounding gloom.

Posted in books | Leave a comment

Retirement HD Radio

Posted on August 17, 2026 by Granger Meador

Back in March 2026, I reviewed the various radio receivers I used from childhood through the early 2000s. I documented my failed attempt to revive my 2003 Cambridge Soundworks 730 clock radio, and how I eventually created automations for our Google Home devices to stream Tulsa’s KWGS NPR station or Bartlesville’s KWON.

I’ve been retired for six weeks, and I will confess that I have yet to use either of those automations. However, I do listen to KWGS in the car. My 2014.5 Toyota Camry has HD Radio, so by default it can pick up the station’s three digital radio transmissions along with the regular FM analog signal. However, the KWGS HD digital signals are so weak that they frequently cut out in my car as it goes up and down the hills of Bartlesville. When 89.5-1 cuts out, the radio switches to analog 89.5, switching back to 89.5-1 when it regains signal strength. The repeated switching creates hiccups since the two are not in audio sync.

Now, when the radio hiccups, I go into Options to disable HD Radio. Sadly, I have not found a way to make that setting “stick”, but in mucking around with the radio, I was reminded that KWGS also broadcasts Jazz 89.5-2 and BBC World Service 89.5-3. I tuned in the jazz station, and I liked it. Too bad for me, though, since it also kept cutting out as I drove up and down in hilly Bartlesville, and there is no analog fallback for it.

Toyota radio options — A weak signal led me to turn off HD Radio on my 2014.5 Camry

I’ll be fine without HD Radio in the car, and I could always pay to restore the car’s SiriusXM satellite radio service if I wanted more options. However, I realized that I would enjoy listening to Jazz 89.5-2 at home when Wendy is away at work.

I watch Techmoan on YouTube, and in a recent post for his Patreon supporters, Mat showed his efforts to upgrade his garden shed workshop building’s external antenna to improve his reception of DAB/DAB+ and his search for a good DAB+ receiver for his component audio setup.

Open this for optional DAB/DAB+ and HD Radio specifics

DAB stands for Digital Audio Broadcasting and is used in Europe and some other areas, but not in the USA. Original DAB has broadcasts using the MP2 codec, typically at a bitrate of 128 kilobits per second or less. DAB+ offers subchannels using the HE-AAC v2 codec and is often 64 kbit/s and thus of worse audio quality than analog frequency modulation signals.

In the USA, FM HD Radio adds digital carriers to traditional 270 kHz-wide analog channels. KWGS HD1 runs at 48 kbit/s with the HDC/HE-AAC codec while it runs HD2 Jazz and HD3 BBC World Service at 24 kbit/s.

That got me to thinking about convenient ways to listen to Jazz 89.5-2 at home. I could buy a nice HD Radio like the Sangean HDR-19. However, it costs $200 and when I’m at home alone I would prefer the background music to be playing in my office, the living room, and the kitchen.

So I created a “Manor” speaker group in Google Home for the Google Nest Hubs in the office and the kitchen and the Google Home Mini in the living room. I discovered I could say, “Hey Google, play Tulsa Jazz radio on Manor” and it would play Jazz 89.5 HD2 on the various speakers via TuneIn. To shut it off, I can just say to any of the devices, “Hey Google, stop.”

In 2018 I purchased Google Nest Hub, Home Mini, and original Google Home devices

However, the audio quality was unimpressive in my office. The Nest Hub is 13′ from my desk, and it has a 1.7″ speaker. I had an original Google Home speaker from 2018 stashed away, and it has a 2″ high excursion speaker with dual 2″ passive radiators that readily outperforms a Nest Hub. So I pulled it out, plugged it in at my office desk, reset it by holding down its mute button for 15 seconds, and then added it back into our Google Home using the app on my iPhone.

That provided much richer bass, and I can now happily stream Jazz 89.5 HD2 across our home. It’s a good life.

Posted in technology | Leave a comment

The Diffusion of Innovations

Posted on August 11, 2026 by Granger Meador

Back in 1957, the Diffusion of Innovations theory was developed by Joe M. Bohlen, George M. Beal and Everett M. Rogers at Iowa State University. It was originally applied to agriculture and home economics, but it was later applied across disciplines. I generally think of myself as an Early Adopter in technology, but I decided to explore my actual categorizations.

The first 1/6 of folks adopting an innovation are split into a small group of Innovators, who desire to be the first to use the latest technology, and a larger fraction of Early Adopters who enjoy new innovations and are comfortable taking social risks but are largely motivated by how an innovation can drive their success. Another 1/3 are the Early Majority who adopt new innovations only after they are proven, with another trailing 1/3 in the Late Majority who are risk averse conservatives. A final 1/6 are Laggards who only use new technology when forced to do so.

I created a chart for 1980-2025 approximating when various innovative technologies appeared to have been in each stage of diffusion, adding a yellow outline for my initial year of investing in each of them. Please note that some innovations originated before 1980.

Approximate diffusion phases, based on Google Search AI queries, with yellow outlines denoting when I bought into a technology

I was an Innovator in home computers, the internet, and electronic books and an Early Adopter of CDs, MP3 players, and online audio. However, my aversion to telephones delayed my purchase of a cell phone until after the majority of American adults already had one, placing me in the Late Majority for that. I made up for that by being an Early Adopter of smartphones, for which telephony was just a minor feature to me.

You’ll notice that some digital audio formats never reached the Laggards stage, as they were steadily supplanted by later ones, as happened previously to the old analog formats of vinyl records, 8-track tapes, and compact cassettes. As for electronic books, they go way back, but they didn’t really get traction until the Amazon Kindle e-ink reader debuted in late 2007, and even now only about 1 out of 4 Americans read them, or about 40% of the 60% who read a book in a given year, so they’ve never even reached Late Majority status.

I found some interesting charts that document the rise, and sometimes the rise and fall, of different innovations. Here’s one on communications technologies:

Communication technologies in the USA during my lifetime [Source]

Telephone Service

The earlier chart shows that we have more than one mobile phone subscription per person these days since some people have multiple cell phones or have a subscription for their smartphone but another for a tablet or smartwatch. Pew Research has a different breakdown by adults, showing that in mid-2025 98% of them had a cellphone, with 91% of them having a smartphone.

While AT&T will be eliminating traditional landline telephone service in almost all states by 2029, about 1/4 still have fixed telephones, no doubt many of them VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) ones that rely on broadband internet. I switch from traditional landline to VoIP at Meador Manor in 2007 and two years later gave up VoIP.

Internet

Landline internet subscriptions per person is not as informative as per household. Pew Research showed that in the 2020s we plateaued with about 80% of U.S. adults subscribing to home broadband, and about 15% of U.S. adults don’t use broadband at home but do own a smartphone.

Audio Formats

My parents owned vinyl records and 8-track tapes. When I was in high school and in my early years as an undergraduate, I bought vinyl records and created compact cassette mix tapes for use in my car. I bought my first compact disc player in 1986, and I have absolutely no use for any of the old analog formats, having endured their many limitations throughout my childhood, although I enjoy Techmoan‘s and Technology Connections‘ explorations of vintage audio tech.

Audio revenues by format over time [Source]

I bought my first iPod back in 2004, making the switch from compact discs to MP3s. They commanded a tiny fraction of music sales revenue at the time, and only about 6% of households had an MP3 player, but Napster and Limewire had made music piracy commonplace at the start of the 21st century and steadily whittled down the immense profits being made on compact discs.

I was never a music pirate, and until 2018 I was listening to over 14,000 music files I had either purchased outright or converted from earlier digital and analog formats. I finally started using some streaming audio when we started using smart home speakers, first with Amazon’s Alexa and later Google Home. To this day, much of my listening is of tracks I purchased for my Apple Music Library, although I mostly stopped purchasing individual tracks before 2020.

Video Formats

I first experienced pre-recorded home video via some short movie excerpts on Standard 8 silent film I checked out from a public library. That was laughably bad, while VHS videotapes seemed a godsend. Until I was a year or more into my undergraduate years, VCRs were still so expensive that I rented them, and on at least one occasion I rented a Sony Betamax since a particular title I wanted to see was available on Beta, but not VHS, at my usual video rental store.

DVDs came out around 1996, and I imagine I was an Early Adopter for those, although I wasn’t an Innovator until HD-DVD came out, which was a mistake. Sometimes my higher risk tolerance does result in setbacks. I bought a Toshiba HD-DVD player in October 2007 amidst a format war between that format and the Blu-ray disc, but HD-DVD lost the war a few months later.

Thus in October 2008 I bought a Blu-ray player, shifting me back into Early Adopter status for the winning format, although I had squandered $350 in 2007 dollars, or over $550 in 2026 dollars, on my HD-DVD misadventure.

It was about then that physical media sales began their long decline, and the final physical format of Ultra HD Blu-ray never caught on with its sales peaking in 2017 and doing nothing to slow down the shift from physical media to streaming.

The Diffusion of Artificial Intelligence

Over a decade ago, I wrote about the transformations from analog to digital, from scheduled broadcast to on-demand, from fixed to mobile computing, and from local to cloud storage. Each of those trends has continued to amplify, and in the 2020s we are amidst a transformation from machine learning to generative artificial intelligence (AI) with large language models.

I wrote a year ago about AI’s potential impacts on employment, and a majority of Americans reported interacting with AI at least several times per week by September 2025. By February 2026, almost half of U.S. adults had used AI chatbots, and about 1 in 4 used them daily.

I have used AI to generate illustrative graphics for some of my blog posts, but now its imagery has flooded social media. It is busy, vibrant, glossy, and sterile.

I asked Google Gemini to apply the Diffusion of Innovations theory to the usage of modern AI, and it generated the following table:

Adopter Category	Cumulative %	Timeframe	Key Characteristics & Milestones
Innovators	2.5%	2017-2022	Initial ChatGPT launch; tech enthusiasts and developers.
Early Adopters	16%	2022-2024	Integration into professional workflows; “Pro” users and students.
Early Majority	50%	2024-2028	Cross-platform integration (Gemini, Copilot); 50% weekly use reached in early 2026.
Late Majority	84%	2028-2033 (Projected)	Use becomes a social/economic necessity; skepticism remains high.
Laggards	100%	2033+ (Projected)	Adoption only after the technology is fully embedded and unavoidable.

However, as computer scientist Michael John Wooldridge noted in the Royal Society’s Michael Faraday Prize Lecture, large language models are not rational minds, they are not sentient, and they are not algorithmic problem solvers.

Slide from the Royal Society’s 2025 Faraday Prize Lecture

Exiting in the Early Majority

I attended multiple technology conference sessions on modern AI in June 2023, when it was still in the Early Adopter stage. I tested an AI chatbot for the school district website in 2024, although ultimately I opted not to deploy it. I led a district AI taskforce that developed a district policy on AI with student and staff usage guidelines and recommended rating scales. A few months out from my retirement, I built some Google Notebook LM tools on district technology and board policies that district administrators can access.

However, I am frankly relieved to have retired before AI enters the Late Majority stage. While I possessed a firm grasp of the impact of earlier technological innovations on our public schools, allowing me to successfully lead us through a 1:1 student computing initiative with learning management systems, I was less sanguine about, and frankly less interested in, adaptations to the world of AI.

I am hopeful that younger folks will be better suited to and more interested in navigating a turbulent time of white-collar job disruptions. In 2024, the Brookings Institution found that more than 30% of all workers could see at least 50% of their occupational tasks disrupted by generative AI, and in 2026 the International Monetary Fund said almost 40% of global jobs are exposed to AI-driven change.

Will I remain an Early Adopter in retirement? Time will tell, but the odds are against it.

Posted in history, technology | Leave a comment

Living Where East Meets West

Posted on August 6, 2026 by Granger Meador

Oklahoma has an unusual amount of geographic diversity. Contrary to ignorant images of a giant dustbowl, the state has low rolling mountains and dense pine forests, cypress swamps, and tall grass prairies, as well as the expected flat and arid high plains. Something that interests me is how climate change is gradually shifting across Oklahoma the divide between the humid, rain-fed East and the arid, drought-prone West of the continental United States.

Our state contains many distinct ecological regions, offering more varied terrain per square mile than any other state as it transitions from the Rocky Mountain foothills and high plains in the northwest to the forests, swamps, and mountain ranges in the southeast.

I grew up in Oklahoma City in the Cross Timbers Transition ecoregion, but I’ve lived more of my life in Bartlesville, which lies in the Osage Cuestas just beyond the eastern edge of the Northern Cross Timbers. You can tell the difference if you compare the Cross Timbers of Osage Hills State Park to the undulating plains east of Bartlesville, which in their natural state would be tall grass prairie.

Back in 1960s, the state’s tourism department began taking advantage of its ecological diversity to promote six different “countries” within the Sooner State.

Red Carpet Country has massive mesas and expansive prairies and is associated with the Cheyenne, Arapaho, Ponca, Pawnee, Otoe-Missouria, Tonkawa, and Kaw tribes and nations.
Great Plains Country has wheat and cotton, stretches of mesas, and granite mountain ranges. It is associated with the Comanche, Kiowa, Apache, Wichita, and Caddo tribes and nations.
Lake & Trail Country has multiple artificial reservoirs, the remnants of the ancient Arbuckle Mountains, and it is associated with the Chickasaw Nation.
Frontier Country is a transition zone with sweeping short-grass prairies changing into woody, hilly terrain from west to east. It is associated with the Absentee-Shawnee, Citizen Potowatomi, Kickapoo, Sac & Fox, and Iowa tribes and nations.
Kiamichi Country has miles of evergreen forests and multiple mountain ranges. It is associated with the Choctaw Nation. Culturally, we know it as Little Dixie.
Green Country has lush rolling hills and lakeside resorts. It is home to the Cherokee, Osage, Muscogee (Creek), Delaware, Quapaw, Modoc, Ottawa, Seneca-Cayuga, Shawnee, and Wyandotte tribes and nations.

Bear in mind that few of those tribes and nations were in the area before white settlement and forced relocations. The region’s prehistoric peoples included the Wichita, the Caddo, and maybe some Osage and Apachean-speaking people.

Google Gemini created this collage for me, which I then tweaked

1951 aerial of the home and three city lots my parents owned in the 1970s

I grew up in Frontier Country in what was once Oklahoma Territory, spending my elementary school years living in the Cross Timbers where rugged post oak and blackjack oak grew on coarse, sandy soils. Our home sat on the middle of three city lots which back then were still filled with 70 blackjack oaks, surviving uncut within the 3.5 square mile Council Grove Military Timber Reservation established in 1874 to construct Fort Reno.

In 1884, barracks in Council Grove housed soldiers who cut timber for the fort. Council Grove was omitted from the 1889 Land Run that opened white settlement in the area, its opening being delayed until December 1899. The older part of our house had been constructed a half-century later.

My best friend and I reveled in raking up the tens of thousands of oak leaves, creating race courses for his Big Wheel and my pedal car. We would catapult ourselves into immense leaf piles. My father had a riding lawnmower and a dedicated leaf shredder to deal with it all, and eventually the dust, mites, and allergies from all of the trees led my parents to relocate.

Elementary school years in the Cross Timbers — My late best friend and I amongst the blackjack oaks

Whenever we headed west from Oklahoma City along I-40, such as to piano contests at Weatherford or to camp at Red Rock Canyon, I was struck by how the flat grasslands contrasted with the hilly and rugged Cross Timbers along the Turner Turnpike when we would drive northeast from OKC toward Tulsa.

I love hiking at the Wichita Mountains and Quartz Mountain Resort in Great Plains Country. Red Carpet Country offers Roman Nose State Park, the Little Sahara sand dunes, and the high distant Black Mesa at the westernmost end of the panhandle. Kiamichi Country’s beautiful forests offer splendid hikes at Robbers Cave and in mountain ranges like the Kiamichi and Winding Stair. In Lake & Trail Country, I enjoy Turner Falls and the Chickasaw National Recreation Area amidst the ancient Arbuckle Mountains. Finally, I have spent 37 of my 60 years living in Green Country in what was once Indian Territory.

Oklahoma’s position near the center of the continental U.S. leads to discussions about whether or not it is truly a southern state as well as whether it is part of the nation’s east or its west. There are no definitive answers, as it straddles various dividing lines, but culturally it is certainly more south and west than north and east.

Back in 1878, geologist and explorer John Wesley Powell proposed that the 100th meridian west line of longitude demarcated the difference between the humid and arid regions. That happens to be most of the western border of Oklahoma.

The aridity gradient has shifted eastward over the past century from the 100th to the 98th meridian

However, when researchers plotted the aridity index across the US from 1979 to 2016, they found that the aridity gradient had shifted to center on the 98th meridian. In Oklahoma, that aligns with Kingfisher, El Reno, Chickasha, Duncan, and Waurika.

By 2100, that gradient will have shifted to the 96th meridian which forms the western edge of Bartlesville and aligns with Tulsa and Okmulgee. In the 22nd century, Osage, Pawnee, and Creek counties will no longer be part of Green Country. The shift in climate is apparent in the droughts that imposed water restrictions in Bartlesville in 2001-2002 and again in 2022-2023.

Thinking about this led me back to a nifty interactive, based on research by the Rhodium group, that models how the continental US might fare with climate change over the coming decades.

They modeled the human climate “niche” to identify regions where temperature and precipitation have been most suitable for humans to live over the past 6,000 years. Bartlesville is currently very suitable, although I find our summers rather miserable.

Here is what the niche looks like by 2070 in a moderate carbon emissions scenario. Bartlesville would remain in the zone, but Oklahoma City would not. That shifting aridity zone is more of a problem for the southern latitudes.

In the case of extreme global warming, which I consider more likely, Bartlesville would be near the southern boundary of the suitable zone. I find it interesting how northern and western New Mexico would become more suitable, along with the area south of the Great Lakes plus North Dakota and much of Montana.

In the high emissions scenario, by mid-century Bartlesville would still only have one wet bulb day per year on average, when the body can no longer cool itself by sweating. So while we’ll have many more days of high temperatures, at least the humidity won’t make it as miserable as it will be in the states east of us.

Washington County would only average a very large fire once per century, while northern Nevada and California, southeastern Oregon, and southwestern Idaho would become a wildfire zone.

Sea level rise, of course, will not be an issue here, but the Chemical Coast of Texas and Louisiana, where 84% of US plastics are produced, will be in trouble, as will most of the eastern seaboard.

Farm crop yields will take a big hit around here while improving in the upper midwest, around the Great Lakes, and surrounding the Rocky Mountains.

Happily, Oklahoma is projected to have little economic damage, unlike our neighbors to the north and south.

Domestic migration patterns show some people moving to areas that will become more livable over time, but the sun belt continues to attract many people, despite the inevitable and difficult adaptations to climate impacts they will face.

Posted in random | Leave a comment

Bartlesville in the State of Sequoyah

Posted on July 31, 2026 by Granger Meador

Alternate histories have been a literary trope for over two thousand years. Livy posed the question, in Parts 17-19 of Book 9 of his From the Founding of the City, “What would have been the results for Rome if she had been engaged in war with Alexander?”

In 1889, Mark Twain wrote of A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court. In 1939, L. Sprague de Camp speculated in Lest Darkness Fall on what might have happened if an American archaeologist of his era were transported to 6th Century Rome. In 1962, Philip K. Dick’s The Man in the High Castle explored a timeline in which Nazi Germany and the Japanese Empire won World War II and partitioned the former United States.

In more recent times, we have multiverses in the Marvel and DC comics and their film franchises, in Star Trek, in 2022’s Everything Everywhere All at Once, and many more.

Let’s briefly explore an alternate timeline in which the Oklahoma Territory, organized in 1890, and Indian Territory, which first originated in 1834, rather than being merged into the state of Oklahoma in 1907, had instead been admitted as the respective separate states of Oklahoma and Sequoyah.

Territories map — Oklahoma and Indian Territories in 1892 [Source]

The proposal for a State of Sequoyah made it as far as a draft constitution with an election in November 1905 in which 56,279 voted in favor of it, 9,073 voted against it, and many more declined to vote. The concept was doomed, since neither Congress nor President Theodore Roosevelt supported it. The Republican-led government feared that the heavily Native American and Southern-leaning Indian Territory would became a new Democratic stronghold if it were granted statehood, and many whites favored aggressive assimilation of the tribes over preserving their sovereignty.

Thus only one state of Oklahoma was admitted, and it was a Democratic stronghold until the 1990s, as I’ve explored in a previous post.

Below is the State of Sequoyah and its counties as determined in the failed constitution.

State of Sequoyah map — [OSU online version]

Bartlesville was situated in the proposed Skiatook County, which was a bit wider than modern-day Washington County and considerably truncated to the north and south.

Terrible AI map — Claude.ai generated this abomination

I wanted an overlay map comparing Oklahoma’s northeastern county boundaries to the State of Sequoyah’s counties. I wondered if an artificial intelligence could save me the effort of creating one. The answer at this point, and with my unpaid access, was No when I tried Google Gemini, ChatGPT, and Claude, with the last of those talking a good game yet producing an absurd abomination.

So I overlaid the State of Sequoyah map over one of modern-day Oklahoma which showed county lines in brown. I dialed down the Sequoyah map’s opacity and traced by hand blue outlines of several of the northeastern Sequoyah counties, adding blue labels.

Overlay of northeast counties of Oklahoma and Sequoyah — My own “natural intelligence” allowed me to craft this overlay

Neither map designated county seats, although we know that Bartlesville has always been the seat of Oklahoma’s Washington County. As for the State of Sequoyah, its constitution held that whichever city in each county received the most votes in the November 1905 election would become the seat.

Newspaper article — A Bartlesville newspaper dismissed the November 1905 referendum

The turnout in “Skiatook County” was pitiful, with only 14 votes cast in Bartlesville, of which only two were residents and the others from country voters, 11 of them from the First Peoples. That in a town which by then had boomed to three or four thousand people, reflecting the disdain many had for two states instead of one being formed from the two territories.

Dewey and Ramona had polls open, but when no one had appeared to vote by noon, they were closed. Other towns in the area, such as Wann, Copan, Ochelata, Vera, and Collinsville, did not even conduct elections.

Skiatook, the county’s namesake, did muster 61 votes, of which 51 favored the constitution and 10 opposed its adoption. Had Congress supported the State of Sequoyah, that would have made Skiatook the county seat, way down in the southwest corner, despite it having perhaps one-tenth of the population of Bartlesville. As it turned out, the town of Skiatook landed in Oklahoma’s Tulsa county, and Washington County also omitted Collinsville while gaining Copan.

I like the inherent symbolism in how the proposed Great Seal of the State of Sequoyah would have inverted the main star when compared to the Great Seal of the State of Oklahoma that was actually adopted two years later.