Today’s postcard from a 1940 Oklahoma souvenir pack is of The Pioneer Woman monument in Ponca City. It was conceived, directed, and financed by Ernest Marland, an oilman, philanthropist, spendthrift, and politician. In 1928 he created a scandal by marrying Lydie, the biological daughter of his first wife’s sister, whom Marland and his first wife had adopted when Lydie was 16. Marland’s first wife later died, and he had the adoption annulled and then married Lydie when he was 54 and she was 28. Marrying his niece and former daughter didn’t prevent Oklahoma from electing him to Congress in 1932 and as governor in 1935.
In the early 1920s, Marland had been asked about commissioning a statue to the vanishing American Indian. Marland answered, “The Indian is not the vanishing American — it’s the pioneer woman.”
Marland staged a design competition in 1926, paying a dozen artists to craft 3-foot bronze sculptures which were exhibited in a dozen cities. Bryant Baker’s model, Confident, was the most popular, and Marland commissioned a monumental version of it for Ponca City, which was unveiled in 1930.
The monument survives. The Pioneer Woman Museum says, “It is a heroic statue is of a young, sun-bonneted pioneer mother, protectively leading her son by the hand, striding confidently, head held high—a young woman of sturdy beauty and dignity whose eyes are fixed on the far southwestern horizon. Courage, determination, and humility in her face and a bible in her hand.”
The Museum adds that the statue is 17 feet tall, weighs 12,000 pounds, and sits upon a 16-foot-high granite base. It cost $300,000 back in 1930.
A Bartlesville Connection
In 1940, Marland faced financial ruin and sold the small bronze models from the competition to fellow oil tycoon Frank Phillips. The individual artists had each been paid $10,000 for their work, but Phillips acquired the bronzes from Marland for just $500 each. They are on display in his Woolaroc Museum near Bartlesville.
Some of the Pioneer Woman sculptures that didn’t make the cut
If you ever go to Ponca City, you can take a look at the monument and its museum, but the town’s star attraction is the impressive Marland Mansion, which has an outbuilding with the contents of sculptor Bryant Baker’s New York studio with copies of many of his works. Marland’s previous home on Grand Avenue, Marland’s Grand Home, is also worth a visit. If you don’t make it to Ponca City, you can still enjoy a virtual tour of the Mansion and an interactive tour of the Grand Home. But you really need to go tour them in person, and be sure to eat at Enrique’s out at the airport and enjoy the puffy chips.
Tomorrow we go for a scenic drive along the Cimarron.
Today’s postcard from a 1940 Oklahoma souvenir pack is of Oklahoma’s Capitol. It is the back cover of the pack and yes, the Capitol looks a bit different these days.
Most obviously, back then there was no dome, and it didn’t get one until the early 21st century. When I was a kid, I thought it appropriate that while the 1914 blueprints included a dome, budget shortfalls and a supply shortage from World War I led to that being cut from the project. The conspicuous absence of a dome decades later effectively symbolized my home state’s struggles.
I worked at the capitol complex in the summer of 1985 as a minimum wage office boy for the Oklahoma State Department of Tourism. On $3.35 per hour, even with free room and board from my parents, I couldn’t afford to eat in the basement cafeteria very often, but there were a few times when I walked along the tunnel from the Will Rogers building to the Capitol for lunch. Frosty Troy, the watchdog publisher of The Oklahoma Observer, could usually be spotted at one of the tables, regaling someone.
One day that summer, I took my lousy Kodak Ektralite 110 camera over with me and photographed the shallow stained glass saucer dome that used to grace the fourth level of the truncated rotunda. Decades after the real dome was added, the remnants of the old saucer dome were put on display in the State Capitol Museum.
Back in 1928, the discovery of the Oklahoma City Oil Field led to oil wells being scattered across the city. They were once so common that there were still stripper wells and tank batteries scattered about my neighborhood when I was a kid. Dozens of active oil wells were drilled near the Capitol.
Oil wells around the state capitol in 1936 [Source]
A Bartlesville Connection
The wells on the capitol grounds included Petunia #1, which was drilled in a flower bed in front of the building in 1941. Fain-Porter Drilling company whipstocked the bore hole for Bartlesville’s Phillips Petroleum, making it a non-vertical directional drill that burrowed beneath the Capitol itself.
A year after my stint at the Capitol, Petunia #1 was plugged by Phillips, its operator and half-owner. That well alone had produced 1.5 million barrels of oil and 1.6 billion cubic feet of gas, providing the state with over $1 million in royalties and gross production taxes…and the Capitol still didn’t have a dome.
It was an oddball distinction. Governor Frank Keating spearheaded a fundraising drive to finally add a dome, and that work began in 2001. Phillips Petroleum was one of the sponsors, donating $3.5 million towards the project’s $22 million cost.
The dome is 157 feet tall with an 80-foot diameter. The outer dome is precast concrete and cast stone, with an inner coffered dome of cast gypsum panels. The gorgeous interior is an interpretation of the state wildflower, the Indian Blanket Gaillardia pulchella.
A 17.5-foot bronze statue of an American Indian warrior, called The Guardian, was created by artist and former state senator Enoch Kelly Haney. He refused the $50,000 commission for the piece. There is a 9-foot bronze replica of it inside the Senate Lounge.
The Guardian atop the dome; the Will Rogers building where I worked in 1985 is at lower left [Source]
You can view many of the artworks decorating the Capitol at the Oklahoma Arts Council’s Oklahoma State Capitol Art Collection website. That does it for this entry in the postcard pack. Tomorrow we head to Ponca City.
One of the YouTube creators I support on Patreon is Henry’s Dime Store Adventures. At the start of 2025, I joined his Postcard Club, so he sends me a handwritten vintage postcard each month. For May 2026, Henry outdid himself, sending me a linen postcard pack with 20 images from Oklahoma, circa 1940.
So on each of the first 20 days of June 2026, I will share with you a postcard and expound about the pictured location. We’ll start with an image shown on the address side of the pack.
A Burning Oil Well…in Texas?
The cover shows a burning oil well. Well, gee, welcome to Oklahoma!
I found separate linen postcard reproductions of that image by the Oklahoma News Company which captioned it as being near Tulsa. However, the original photograph was actually taken by Jack Nolan on April 26, 1930 of the Skelly-Amerado University No. 1 well in Ector County, Texas. Nolan had been informed that the well, just west of the Concho Bluffs, would be shot with 420 quarts of nitroglycerin at 3,723 feet to increase its production. The typical gusher became a fire when the shot came in contact with the steel crown block, sparking the explosion. It took over 25 hours to control the fire.
So right off the bat we have an anomaly. The attention-grabbing cover image of the Oklahoma souvenir folder was a burning oil well that wasn’t even located here, but instead in our much larger and flamboyant neighbor to the south.
A Bartlesville Connection
I will bring out some Bartlesville connection to each of the postcards, and of course in this case I can’t help but think of the Nellie Johnstone #1 well in Johnstone Park, which was the first commercial oil well in Oklahoma.
The Nellie Johnstone blew in on March 25, 1897 as a wildcat well named for the six-year-old daughter of community leader William Johnstone. Wildcatter Michael Cudahy made a deal with George Keeler, William Johnstone, Frank Overlees, and other community leaders to drill the well. Keeler’s stepdaughter Jennie Cass dropped the Go-Devil to blow in the well, and thankfully it gushed without igniting.
It was producing 30 barrels a day in 1903 when it became commercially viable, thanks to the Santa Fe railroad reaching Bartlesville to transport its output. During its productive life, it produced over 100,000 barrels of oil. It was plugged in 1947, and replica rigs were erected over it in 1948, 1964, and 2008. You can learn more about it in the Block 2 lot 7 slides of my Historic Downtown Bartlesville series.
Oh, and the original Nellie Johnstone derrick was destroyed by fire, but not due to a bad shot. Rather, after it blew in, the well was capped to await the arrival of the railroad. However, oil seeped from it and pooled. During a cold winter in the late 1890s, a group of children ice-skating on the frozen river built a bonfire which accidentally ignited the seep, and the fire tracked back to the well and destroyed the derrick.
The kicker? One of the young people in that skating party was little Nellie Johnstone.
Linen Postcards
I am not a postcard aficionado, so I had to look up what a linen postcard was, given that the ones I have been sent were clearly not printed on fabric. Instead, they are inexpensive, high-rag cotton paper embossed with a textured crosshatch pattern that only mimics the feel of linen cloth.
During the Great Depression and World War II, standard cardstock had trouble absorbing newly introduced brightly colored ink dyes. So Curt Teich & Co. in Chicago and other postcard printers embossed the paper, increasing the surface area so ink would dry much faster. The images often started as black-and-white photographs that artists heavily covered and retouched.
Teich pioneered the offset printing process in which an inked image is transferred (or “offset”) from a plate to a rubber blanket and then to the printing surface of the paper. Teich began using a five-color process in 1931, adding a darker blue color to the usual CMYK palette of cyan, magenta, yellow, and the “key” color of black.
Offset printing presses at Curt Teich Company [Source]
Linen postcards were phased out after World War II when the realistic, glossy photochrome printing process became the industry standard.
The Sooner State
The inside of the pack cover had some text about the state. It is a dry-as-bones summary of the early days of white settlement which I can’t recommend you bother reading. It certainly doesn’t read like a tourist tract to me.
Pseudonyms are invented for various reasons. Edith Mary Pargeter became “Ellis Peters” to separate her mystery stories from her other work. Samuel Longhorne Clemens experimented with the pen names “Josh,” “Sergeant Fathom,” and “Thomas Jefferson Snodgrass” before hitting upon “Mark Twain”. The cousins Frederic Dannay, birth name Daniel Nathan, and Manfred Bennington Lee, birth name Emanuel Benjamin Lepofsky, adopted the “Ellery Queen” pseudonym for the detective character they crafted, who supposedly wrote his own books.
Pen names sometimes disguised gender or ethnicity, in an attempt to boost sales, but Leonard Knapp evidently used them, along with some fictional biographical details, to seem more exotic. Born in rural Minnesota in 1915, he re-invented his father as a poor sharecropper of part-Spanish extraction and became best known as Lester del Rey. The mischievous man would sometimes claim his actual name was the ludicrous Ramón Felipe San Juan Mario Silvio Enrico Smith Heathcourt-Brace Sierra y Alvarez del Rey y de los Verdes. He also published works as Philip St. John, Erik van Lhin, John Alvarez, Marion Henry, Philip James, Charles Satterfield and Edson McCann, with the last two pen names sometimes also used by Frederik Pohl. There were reportedly eight additional pen names over the years.
Attempts to ascertain factual information about his early life run into obstacles. Reportedly records showed his birthplace as Clydesdale, which might have referred to a community in the Saratoga Township. Wikipedia offered this interesting tidbit: “He also claimed that his family was killed in a car accident in 1935. In reality, the accident only killed his first wife.”
Well, gee, what’s the story behind that? I ordered an old paperback copy of the referenced source, Sam Moskowitz’s Seekers of Tomorrow of 1965. It was a collective biography that profiled 22 authors of classic science fiction, and consisted mostly of reprints of Moskowitz’s articles in Amazing Stories from 1961 to 1964. I also ordered the January 2008 issue of Locus, which had a brief item on his background.
Moskowitz was clearly just retelling some of Lester/Leonard’s yarns, and he wrote that Lester was working with some bootleggers in a New Mexico town in 1930 when he met a girl and proposed to her that same day. The boy was supposedly only 15 while the girl of legal age, and supposedly three months after their marriage she was thrown from a horse and died from her injuries. Later in the tales is the claim that his family, save for one full sister, died in a car accident in 1935.
Well, it seems there was a mysterious first wife, but Leonard’s sister, Sara Knapp, said he broke all ties with his family after leaving home in 1931 and that he “seemed to be ashamed of where he lived and of his folks”. She also said the 1935 car accident killed his first wife, not his blood family, when he would have been about 20 years old.
By the mid-1970s, del Rey included autobiographical comments throughout his collection Early del Rey, mentioning reading various literary classics as a boy in a little farming community of southeastern Minnesota, and in high school discovering science fiction magazines. He acknowledged attending George Washington University in the District of Columbia in the early 1930s on a partial scholarship while living with an uncle, dropping out after two years, and doing various odd jobs. However, he made no mention of his first marriage nor a car accident, although he did say he was in poor health for awhile before 1937.
del Rey’s 1948 collection of short stories, And some were human, had this nerdy blurb on the back of its dust jacket:
Lester del Rey in the 1940s
Lester del Rey’s first wail of protest against a life-sentence to Earth sounded in 1915 under the dual-personality sign of Gemini. In this case, astrology was correct. His nature was divided between magnificent laziness and hopelessly insatiable curiosity. As any scientist knows, after laboring ten years to learn one subject, the two are incompatible, and sure to lead to early schizophrenia. But he was saved from this by his own astounding discovery that a net weight of 105 pounds was barely enough to support a single personality, and utterly inadequate for the development of two. He promptly ceased growing, and only the dominant laziness remained.
Thus a writer was born! There is no easier way to earn a living — provided three skipped meals a day form a satisfactory diet; and no surer preventative against adding enough weight for that dread split in personality. After his discovery of a 1929 Gernsback magazine, it was perhaps inevitable that his frustrated desire for knowledge of all things should lead him into dream-worlds of fantasy and the bright Utopias of tomorrow. As some of the meek who shall inherit the dirt turn to poetry, so he turned to fiction. The result is inside.
Statistics: Tired of college after two years; tried office work, metal forming, restaurant work, bibliographic research, etc., but found they interfered with loafing and cheerfully abandoned them. Interests run from archeology to zoömorphisms; and chiefly run from labor. Ambition — to sell enough copies of this book to retire.
In my younger days, I bought several paperbacks with the Del Rey imprint, which “Lester” had established with his fourth wife. Already a friend of del Rey, Judy-Lynn Benjamin married him after the death of his third wife, and she was a respected editor, born with dwarfism, whom the gifted author Isaac Asimov described as “incredibly intelligent, quick-witted, hard-driving” and “generally recognized (especially by me) as one of the top editors in the business” while the troubled but talented Philip K. Dick called her a “master craftsman” and “the best editor I’ve ever worked with”.
My first del Rey book
I read a few of his short stories, but the only del Rey novel I had read was not part of their imprint, but rather authored by Lester del Rey as part of the John C. Winston Company’s 37-volume series of juvenile science fiction novels published in the 1950s for teen-aged boys.
I came across that 1953 book, Attack from Atlantis, on the shelves of the Leo C. Mayfield Junior High library in the late 1970s. Having enjoyed the movies Run Silent, Run Deep and Ice Station Zebra (a few years before the incredible Das Boot was filmed), the cover art of a submarine making a steep dive into the deep compelled me to read it. It was memorable, but its science was so goofy that I did not read more of his work. One online source claimed the quality of his work declined once he began writing full-time in 1950, as he increased his output to stay afloat. The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction describes him as “a versatile but rather erratic writer who never fulfilled his early promise”.
There were crystals in del Rey’s 1953 novel that formed force field bubbles, and George Pal‘s worst movie, Atlantis, the Lost Continent of 1961, had volcanic power crystals that were used to create a death ray. However, that is about the only overlap, and the movie’s scriptwriter Daniel Mainwaring had unfaithfully adapted a 1948 play by Gerald Hargreaves, Atalanta: A Story of Atlantis: A Fantasy with Music, which itself had been partly based on Ignatius Donnelly’s pseudoarchaeological book Atlantis: The Antediluvian World of 1882. As Kirby Ferguson says, “Everything is a Remix.”
When I was a teenager, one of my uncles gave me a slew of science fiction paperbacks. The most physically intriguing ones were Ace Doubles, which were little tête-bêche format books published from 1952 to 1973. Each contained two novellas, with the front cover and interior of one novella rotated by 180 degrees and bound back-to-back with the front cover and interior of the other.
The most memorable of those which I read was Ted White’s Android Avenger. I judged the Ace Doubles by their covers, and for me, that was a clear winner over Lester del Rey’s The Sky Is Falling.
Which of these would you rather read?
Adam & Eve from The Bible Story
As a childhood fan of The Six Million Dollar Man television series, a man with a metal skull was far more appealing to me than artwork that reminded me more of something from a The Bible Story sample book that always graced the waiting room of my pediatrician. Was that Ace cover supposed to depict Adam & Eve in hell? I’ll admit that I never got past that, given my ambivalence about Lester’s earlier Attack from Atlantis for kids.
It originated as the short story “No More Stars” by “Charles Satterfield” in BeyondFantasy Fiction‘s July 1954 issue. The man who was actually Leonard Knapp expanded that into a novella and it was joined with his novella Badge of Infamy in 1963’s Galaxy Magabook #1 and finally reprinted as one of the last Ace Doubles in 1973.
Galaxy Magazine, sometimes known as Galaxy Science Fiction, had published companion novels in the 1950s, but then sold that line to Beacon Books, which specialized in softcore pornography. When Galaxy decided to try to get back into the book business, it was with the Magabooks, each consisting of two novellas by the same author. However, only three of the Magabooks were released, featuring Lester del Rey, then Jack Williamson, and finally Theodore Sturgeon.
The story opened well, with a man being brought back from the dead via an odd combination of scientific and seemingly magical methods.
“Dave Hanson! By the power of the true name be summoned cells and humors, ka and id, self and—”
Dave Hanson! The name came swimming through utter blackness, sucking at him, pulling him together out of nothingness. Then, abruptly, he was aware of being alive, and surprised. He sucked in on the air around him, and the breath burned in his lungs. He was one of the dead— there should be no quickening of breath within him!
He caught a grip on himself, fighting the fantasies of his mind, and took another breath of air. This time it burned less, and he could force an awareness of the smells around him. But there was none of the pungent odor of the hospital he had expected. Instead, his nostrils were scorched with a noxious odor of sulfur, burned hair and cloying incense.
He gagged on it. His diaphragm tautened with the sharp pain of long-unused muscles, and he sneezed.
“A good sign,” a man’s voice said. “The followers have accepted and are leaving. Only a true being can sneeze. But unless the salamander works, his chances are only slight.”
This Dave Hanson was not a hockey player, playwright, roboticist, jazz pianist, or investment advisor. He was a computer repairman who had been crushed by a bulldozer, and mysteriously revived in the alternate world of Terah for a mission: prevent the sky from falling.
The story was fast, and while it had some funny inventiveness, I think it probably worked better as a short story than as a novella. Del Rey just wasn’t that great of a writer, although he certainly proved his worth as an editor of mass-market paperbacks.
The success of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings led del Rey to realize there was demand for an unformed genre that would become known as “fantasy”. He published Terry Brooks’ The Sword of Shannara, a ripoff of Tolkien but a page-turner that my best friend of the 1980s read again and again. The del Reys also published Stephen Donaldson’s Lord Foul’s Bane, unworried about a protagonist who was incredibly unsympathetic, and my friend also read that multiple times.
Lester understood how to sell to that era’s mall bookstores of B. Dalton and Waldenbooks, and fellow editor David Hartwell delineated del Rey’s formula for success: “The books would be original novels set it invented worlds in which magic works. Each would have a male central character who triumphed over the forces of evil (usually associated with technical knowledge of some variety) by innate virtue, and with the help of a tutor or tutelary spirit.”
Del Rey hit it big with these fantasy books
That certainly worked for Piers Anthony, a forty-something science fiction author, who followed it to write his first fantasy novel as a mass-market paperback original in 1977. By 1994, Anthony had published seventeen more of his “Xanth” books, and by 2026 there were a whopping 49 of them, although he has moved from one publisher to another whenever he felt editors were tampering too much with his work. The guy is still churning them out in his 90s!
My late friend also read Xanth, and he convinced me to try a couple of them, but they quickly wore thin for me. I was more impressed with Anthony’s first Apprentice Adept trilogy, which mixed science fiction with fantasy, although I didn’t read the next phaze (pun intended) of that series featuring a later generation of protagonists.
Both Piers Anthony and Lester del Rey were creatives who found success in their writing, but Lester truly came into his own, with the help of Judy-Lynn, as an editor. In the future, I’ll be far more likely to read an author’s works that he edited than Lester’s own output.
Have you ever heard of Sherwood Anderson? I had not, until I noticed his book Winesburg, Ohio listed at #24 on Modern Library’s self-serving 100 Best Novels of the 20th Century.
The Greatest Books of All Time meta-analysis ranked it as 304th, although a year earlier it had been 279th. My reading of it in May 2026 made it the 21st of the Modern Library 100 that I had read.
I had just finished six genre fiction books, four mysteries and two classic science fiction fix-ups, and I was ready for something more literary. I downloaded an EPUB3 of it from Standard Ebooks and used Send to Kindle. Despite their claims of more rigorous proofing, I spotted three typographical errors in that version. You can also read it at Project Gutenberg.
Happily, given my fragmented attention span in the last weeks of my occupancy of a work office, Anderson’s 1919 book was a short story cycle. It was, in a way, an early fix-up in that ten of its twenty-two stories had been previously published, in slightly different versions, in various literary magazines between 1916 and 1918.
The stories are set in the titular town at the turn of the 19th century into the 20th, which was loosely based on Clyde, Ohio, where Anderson had lived from 1884 to 1896, when he was roughly ages eight to twenty. His father, a former Union soldier and harness-maker, had moved the family there after his drinking led to financial difficulties in Caledonia, Ohio.
Anderson’s father could barely support the family as an occasional sign-painter and paperhanger, and his mother took in washing. Sherwood earned the nickname “Jobby” for his efforts to find various odd jobs to help out, leaving school at age fourteen after nine months in high school. He spent the rest of his time in Clyde as a “newsboy, errand boy, waterboy, cow-driver, stable groom, and perhaps printer’s devil, not to mention assistant to Irwin Anderson [his father], Sign Painter”.
Anderson later went to night school, did a short stint in the army and went to Cuba for the Spanish-American War, but fighting had ceased four months prior to his company’s arrival there. At age twenty-three, he enrolled in a preparatory school on the campus of Wittenburg University. While he was working at a boardinghouse, a high school teacher introduced him to fine literature. Anderson was one of eight students chosen to give a commencement speech, impressing an advertising manager enough to give him a job in the firm.
Anderson in 1923
Anderson worked at the advertising firm for six years, married, and became a sales manager for a mail-order firm. A batch of defective incubators was his undoing, with Anderson suffering a nervous breakdown from months of answering hundreds of complaint letters.
The Andersons moved to another town in Ohio, where he had several successful businesses, but Anderson had a second nervous breakdown in 1912 and abandoned his wife and their three children. Thankfully, she came from a prosperous family, but his behavior reminded me of how the architect and egotist Frank Lloyd Wright treated his own family in 1909. Anderson moved to Chicago, was divorced in 1916, and he would marry three more times, with each marriage enduring about eight years.
He wrote a couple of inferior novels before producing Winesburg, Ohio. That story cycle, written when he was in his early 40s, is generally recognized as his best work. While he produced a handful of additional highly regarded short stories and a few novels of varying success in the 1920s, his work after the start of the Great Depression is generally regarded less favorably, although it still produced quotable passages.
In 1941, at age 64, he swallowed a toothpick at a New York cocktail party before embarking on a cruise to South America. The toothpick caused internal damage that led to peritonitis, and he died in Panama.
Anderson’s body was buried on the slope of a grassy hilltop in Virginia, near the border with Tennessee and North Carolina. His tombstone, a modernist creation by one of his friends, the sculptor Wharton Esherick, bears the epitaph Anderson had composed for it: “Life, Not Death, Is the Great Adventure”.
His greatest work included suggestive sexual overtones, but one source declaims, “…it is not an American classic because it introduced hitherto taboo subjects and experimented with new forms of structure in novel and tale. It is a classic because it is a deeply moving book about the loneliness and frustration of ordinary people…because it portrays the difficulty of communicating with one another yet clings to the tenuous hope that love and understanding can bridge the moat that isolates each of us…”
Decades ago, I devoured Ray Bradbury’s stories about Green Town, Illinois—a fictionalized version of his own childhood in Waukegan. Bradbury infused many of his stories about the Green Town of the 1920s with intense nostalgia, lyrical prose, and the blending of magical wonder with the bittersweet realities of life, as experienced through 12-year-old Douglas Spalding.
That contrasts greatly with Anderson, who imbued his fictional Winesburg of the 1890s with profound isolation, frustration, and repressed desires of small-town life. Anderson featured “grotesque” characters—lonely individuals defined by singular, obsessive truths—who struggled to communicate, all tied together by the central observer, young reporter George Willard, who matures through the cycle from an adolescent boy to a young man.
Bradbury was the more gifted writer, but his romanticized style can become cloying. Anderson was far gloomier and more adult, including sexuality that was most unusual in 1919.
I enjoyed the themes of most of his tales, even though they were almost all downers. He did provide a bit of relief with the humor in the story A Man of Ideas, with its lively and even lovable, if exhausting, verbose protagonist. I also liked the linkages between The Strength of God and The Teacher, with the strong contrast of a Peeping Tom pastor’s interpretation of a night’s events with that of the frustrated teacher he spied upon.
Anderson effectively sketched recognizable oddities of personality, several of which I have encountered over the decades. I also related to the adolescent confusion of young George, which revived memories from my teenage years. I was struck by the desperation of Alice Hindman in Adventure, who runs naked out into the street one night, only for her wild act to end without anyone else ever knowing about it, and her tragic embrace of a future that holds nothing but more loneliness.
Ball State professor Bill Sutton claimed that Anderson observed people in Chicago and transplanted them to his fictional town, and the book has been characterized as an exposé of the hypocrisy, frustration, and inhibition behind a typical small town’s façade of gentility. However, it is more a book about, as Irving Howe wrote, “extreme states of being, the collapse of men and women who have lost their psychic bearings and now hover, at best tolerated, at the edge of the little community in which they live.”
Howe’s analysis includes:
It was in the freedom of the city, in its readiness to put up with deviant styles of life, that Anderson found the strength to settle accounts with—but also to release his affection for—the world of small-town America. The dream of an unconditional personal freedom, that hazy American version of utopia, would remain central throughout Anderson’s life and work. It was an inspiration; it was a delusion.
…
Anderson evokes a depressed landscape in which lost souls wander about; they make their flitting appearances mostly in the darkness of night, these stumps and shades of humanity. This vision has its truth, and at its best it is a terrible if narrow truth—but it is itself also grotesque, with the tone of the authorial voice and the mode of composition forming muted signals of the book’s content. Figures like Dr. Parcival, Kate Swift, and Wash Williams are not, nor are they meant to be, “fully-rounded” characters such as we can expect in realistic fiction; they are the shards of life, glimpsed for a moment, the debris of suffering and defeat. In each story one of them emerges, shyly or with a false assertiveness, trying to reach out to companionship and love, driven almost mad by the search for human connection. In the economy of Winesburg these grotesques matter less in their own right than as agents or symptoms of that “indefinable hunger” for meaning which is Anderson’s preoccupation.
I suppose Anderson in his way set the stage for the infamous Peyton Place of 1956, a novel by Grace Metalious which was filled with secrets, sex, and hypocrisy in a small New England town. Peyton Place, which I read in 2023, has a stronger sense of plot and is noisy, sensational, and accusatory, while the more symbolic Winesburg, Ohio is quiet, moody, and empathetic.
Anderson’s abandonment of his wife and children makes an appearance in The Untold Lie. A young troublesome farmworker has impregnated a woman and asks a fellow field worker, who is a henpecked husband with a half-dozen scrawny children, if he should follow in his footsteps and marry his lover. The older man turns and walks away, providing no answer. Later, sent to town to get groceries, he runs to intercept the young worker, intending to tell him to not settle down. However, the young worker has already decided to get married, and the older man never proffers his advice, which he then discounts as an untold lie. Knowing Anderson’s behavior, his ambiguous treatment of the topic is interesting.
I was grateful that Anderson gave his young reporter, George, a character arc. He is not merely a sounding board for the various misfits, but has romantic relationships throughout his adolescence that begin as shallow and purely sexual, progress to confusing, and culminate in one which has the potential of becoming something deeper and more mature.
The final stories have some beautiful moments. In Death, a doctor speaks to George’s mother:
“Love is like a wind stirring the grass beneath trees on a black night,” he had said. “You must not try to make love definite. It is the divine accident of life. If you try to be definite and sure about it and to live beneath the trees, where soft night winds blow, the long hot day of disappointment comes swiftly and the gritty dust from passing wagons gathers upon lips inflamed and made tender by kisses.”
And the penultimate story, Sophistication, has this marvelous evocation:
There is something memorable in the experience to be had by going into a fair ground that stands at the edge of a Middle Western town on a night after the annual fair has been held. The sensation is one never to be forgotten. On all sides are ghosts, not of the dead, but of living people. Here, during the day just passed, have come the people pouring in from the town and the country around. Farmers with their wives and children and all the people from the hundreds of little frame houses have gathered within these board walls. Young girls have laughed and men with beards have talked of the affairs of their lives. The place has been filled to overflowing with life. It has itched and squirmed with life and now it is night and the life has all gone away. The silence is almost terrifying. One conceals oneself standing silently beside the trunk of a tree and what there is of a reflective tendency in his nature is intensified. One shudders at the thought of the meaninglessness of life while at the same instant, and if the people of the town are his people, one loves life so intensely that tears come into the eyes.
The sombre and muted beauty of the final stories, after the “terrible if narrow truths” in Anderson’s previous “shards of life”, struck home. My eyes stung as I read of George Willard’s Departure from his home town, with him not thinking of big or dramatic things, like his mother’s death, his leaving home, or his uncertain future. Instead, George thought of little things, those little moments that formed “a background on which to paint the dreams of his manhood.”
I’m quite glad to have read Winesburg, Ohio. It is widely regarded as Anderson’s pinnacle, but F. Scott Fitzgerald is known to have rated Anderson’s Many Marriages of 1923 as his best novel. It has been summarized thusly: “A psychological novel exploring a middle-aged Midwestern washing machine manufacturer’s rebellion against conventional marriage, sexual repression, and societal expectations.”
I’m more likely to eventually take that up than Anderson’s only bestseller, Dark Laughter of 1925, which has been described as being “about a man who abandons his life for a simpler one, only to find new complexities in a romance with his employer’s wife, contrasted with the ‘dark laughter’ of Black servants who observe the white characters’ struggles”. That book was influenced by James Joyce’s Ulysses and uses a stream-of-consciousness style which usually aggravates me, and Hemingway penned a parody of it, mocking the pretensions of Anderson’s style and characters.
I certainly need time to digest Winesburg, Ohio before taking on anything deep. So my next Kindle read will be something that first caught my eye in an Ace Double when I was a teenager, but which I never actually read. Lester del Rey’s The Sky is Falling, which first appeared as a short story in 1954 and as a novella in 1963, has itself fallen into the public domain, and is said to have a fast pace, no explicit content, and an inventive and lighthearted style. Time for a wade in the shallows.